Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 1

Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Proxy Deck

Non-Foil
$40.00 $50.00
Skip to product information
Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 1
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 1
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 2
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 3
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 4
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 5
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 6
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 7
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 8
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 9
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 10
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 1
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 2
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 3
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 4
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 5
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 6
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 7
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 8
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 9
  • Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Commander proxy deck - image 10
Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Proxy Deck

Mothman Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters Proxy Deck

4.9 · 440 reviews on Etsy
$40.00 $50.00

Bundle & save — mix and match any decks

2 decks 5% off $38/deck 3 decks 10% off $36/deck 4 decks 15% off $34/deck 5+ decks 20% off $32/deck
Card Type
  • Free U.S. shipping
  • Printed in the U.S.
  • Secure checkout
  • Save up to 20% on bundles

What’s in the box

  • The complete decklist, ready to play
  • Every token the deck makes
  • 330 GSM black-core cardstock
  • Glossy finish · foil upgrade available

Made to order. Every deck is printed and shipped from the U.S. Please allow 3–5 business days for your order to ship out.

Free strategy guideHow to Play the Sultai Mill +1/+1 Counters DeckGame plan, key cards, combos and stats Read the guide

This list is Sultai mill and +1/+1 counters. Every time nonland cards are milled, from any library, the commander spreads +1/+1 counters across your creatures.

The deck mills every turn, hands out rad counters, doubles counters, and wins with a huge board or a mill combo loop.

How it plays

  • Ramp and set up. Mana rocks and land ramp get the commander out on turn three or four, ahead of a counter doubler.
  • Mill every turn. Mill creatures, artifacts and rad counters mill cards every turn, and each batch grows your board.
  • Win on board or by decking. Attack with a team full of counters, or mill whole libraries with big mill effects.

What you get

  • The full 100-card Commander deck, card for card the decklist below
  • Tokens for everything the deck makes
  • Matching custom art across every card
  • Printed on 330 GSM black-core card stock with industrial UV printers
  • Fits standard sleeves like Dragon Shield and KMC
  • Made to order and shipped from the U.S. Allow 3–5 business days to ship

Power level

Bracket 3 (Upgraded). A clear step up from preconstructed decks, built for mid-to-high power casual tables.

Unofficial proxy cards for casual and playtest use. Not tournament legal. Not affiliated with or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast.

Questions

Are these real Magic cards?

No. These are unofficial, high-quality proxy cards printed for casual play — perfect for testing a deck, playing with friends, or enjoying a full Commander deck without hunting down every expensive card. They are not affiliated with or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast.

Can I use them in tournaments?

No. Proxies aren’t legal in sanctioned events. They’re made for kitchen-table games, Commander nights and any playgroup that allows proxies — always check with your group first.

What are the cards printed on?

330 GSM black-core cardstock with a glossy finish. The black core keeps the cards opaque, so nothing shows through from the back.

Will they fit my sleeves?

Yes. Every card is standard Magic size (63 × 88 mm), so standard sleeves such as Dragon Shield or KMC fit perfectly.

Do you offer bundle discounts?

Yes — the more decks you buy, the more you save: 5% off 2 decks, 10% off 3, 15% off 4 and 20% off 5 or more. Mix and match any decks, foil or non-foil. The discount is applied automatically in your cart, no code needed. Build your bundle.

How long until my deck ships?

Each deck is printed to order in the U.S. Please allow 3–5 business days for it to ship out. Shipping within the U.S. is free.

What’s the difference between Foil and Non-Foil?

Both versions contain the exact same cards, printed on the same 330 GSM black-core cardstock. Non-Foil cards have a glossy finish; Foil cards add a shiny foil layer on every card for extra flash at the table.

Do you take custom deck orders?

Yes — send us your commander and decklist on the custom decks page. For anything else, contact us and we’ll get back to you.

Inside the deck

The Wise Mothman

100cards
Bracket 3power level
3.09avg. mana value
35lands
2token types

Mana curve

00
51
232
163
94
45
66
17+

Card types

  • Creatures27
  • Instants10
  • Sorceries9
  • Artifacts10
  • Enchantments8
  • Lands35

Strategy: Mill

Full decklist (100 cards + 16 tokens)

Commander

  • 1 The Wise Mothman

Creatures (27)

  • 1 Ruin Crab
  • 1 Cathedral Acolyte
  • 1 Thrummingbird
  • 1 Vexing Radgull
  • 1 Winding Constrictor
  • 1 Evolution Sage
  • 1 Evolution Witness
  • 1 Feral Ghoul
  • 1 Glowing One
  • 1 Hancock, Ghoulish Mayor
  • 1 Infesting Radroach
  • 1 Kami of Whispered Hopes
  • 1 Rampaging Yao Guai
  • 1 Raul, Trouble Shooter
  • 1 Tato Farmer
  • 1 Bloatfly Swarm
  • 1 Corpsejack Menace
  • 1 Nightkin Ambusher
  • 1 The Master, Transcendent
  • 1 Marcus, Mutant Mayor
  • 1 Mirelurk Queen
  • 1 Syr Konrad, the Grim
  • 1 Alpha Deathclaw
  • 1 Muldrotha, the Gravetide
  • 1 Screeching Scorchbeast
  • 1 Strong, the Brutish Thespian
  • 1 Agent Frank Horrigan

Instants (10)

  • 1 Assassin's Trophy
  • 1 Contaminated Drink
  • 1 Counterspell
  • 1 Heroic Intervention
  • 1 Ripples of Potential
  • 1 Inspiring Call
  • 1 Mutational Advantage
  • 1 Putrefy
  • 1 Atomize
  • 1 Radstorm

Sorceries (9)

  • 1 Reanimate
  • 1 Farseek
  • 1 Find
  • 1 Maddening Cacophony
  • 1 Nature's Lore
  • 1 Nuclear Fallout
  • 1 Rampant Growth
  • 1 Cultivate
  • 1 Casualties of War

Artifacts (10)

  • 1 Sol Ring
  • 1 Arcane Signet
  • 1 Mesmeric Orb
  • 1 Mindcrank
  • 1 Nuka-Nuke Launcher
  • 1 Power Fist
  • 1 Talisman of Curiosity
  • 1 Talisman of Dominance
  • 1 Talisman of Resilience
  • 1 The Water Crystal

Enchantments (8)

  • 1 Bloodchief Ascension
  • 1 Hardened Scales
  • 1 Branching Evolution
  • 1 Fraying Sanity
  • 1 Guardian Project
  • 1 Struggle for Project Purity
  • 1 Inexorable Tide
  • 1 Vault 12: The Necropolis

Lands (35)

  • 1 Breeding Pool
  • 1 Command Tower
  • 1 Darkwater Catacombs
  • 1 Drowned Catacomb
  • 1 Evolving Wilds
  • 1 Exotic Orchard
  • 5 Forest
  • 1 Hinterland Harbor
  • 4 Island
  • 1 Mariposa Military Base
  • 1 Mortuary Mire
  • 1 Nesting Grounds
  • 1 Opulent Palace
  • 1 Overflowing Basin
  • 1 Overgrown Tomb
  • 1 Path of Ancestry
  • 1 Sunken Hollow
  • 4 Swamp
  • 1 Tainted Isle
  • 1 Tainted Wood
  • 1 Temple of Deceit
  • 1 Temple of Malady
  • 1 Temple of Mystery
  • 1 Viridescent Bog
  • 1 Woodland Cemetery

Tokens (16)

  • 8 Radiation
  • 8 Zombie Mutant 2/2
Read the full deck guide →

The real thing

What your deck looks like in hand

Every deck is printed the same way on 330 GSM black-core stock.

  • Foil finish
  • Front and back
  • Black core, torn in halfBlack core, torn in half
  • A full deck

Shown: our Giada and Krenko decks, including foil cards.

Reviews

What players are saying

4.9

average from 440 reviews on Etsy

Read every review on Etsy →
  • ★★★★★
    “I bought this as a gift for my wife and she LOVES it! It's a fantastic deck. Very high quality and shipped quickly!!”
    Kaitlyn Etsy review · Oct 10, 2026
  • ★★★★★
    “Great proxy deck, quality materials were as described. I've been using them and they feel just like real mtg cards.”
    Ren Etsy review · Oct 19, 2026
  • ★★★★★
    “Item shipped fast. I appreciate how cohesive the art is. Deck plays well”
    Roman Etsy review · Oct 17, 2026
  • ★★★★★
    “Nice quality cards at an unbeatable price. I have already ordered several more decks.”
    Evan Etsy review · Oct 17, 2026
  • ★★★★★
    “Customer service answered all questioned i had professionally and timely, the cards feel good and the art work is amazing”
    Sy Etsy review · Oct 14, 2026
  • ★★★★★
    “The art style is amazing it's my pods favorite to see.”
    Hayato Etsy review · Oct 8, 2026
  • ★★★★★
    “I paid the extra for the foil in this deck and it was definitely worth it the quality it amazing and I will buy again.”
    Robin Etsy review · Oct 15, 2026
  • ★★★★★
    “I've been wanting this deck for so long and now I have a very, very nice looking deck. I can't wait to play with it.”
    Alan Etsy review · Oct 19, 2026
  • ★★★★★
    “Best deck proxies. I love the art work and the orders get sent and arrive quick.”
    Shane Etsy review · Oct 8, 2026
  • ★★★★★
    “I may not be the smartest at Commander, but I'll have the prettiest cards!”
    Etsy buyer Etsy review · Oct 19, 2026
  • ★★★★★
    “High quality and fast shipping. And a great proxy deck! Definitely will buy more.”
    Robert Etsy review · Oct 5, 2026
  • ★★★★★
    “Fast shipping, product was exactly as described.”
    Cameron Etsy review · Oct 22, 2026

Bundle offer

Build your bundle — save up to 20%

2 decks 5% off · 3 decks 10% · 4 decks 15% · 5+ decks 20%, applied automatically in your cart. Tap the gold bag on any deck to add it without leaving this page.